Are application fees refundable if a tenant is denied?

Tenant Screening and Application Fees in New Hampshire: Are Application Fees Refundable if a Tenant is Denied?

As a landlord in New Hampshire, understanding the legal landscape surrounding tenant screening and application fees is essential for smooth rental operations and maintaining a good relationship with prospective tenants. One common question landlords often face is whether application fees are refundable if a tenant’s application is denied. This guide provides an overview specific to New Hampshire’s laws and best practices regarding application fees and tenant screening.

---

Overview of Tenant Screening and Application Fees in New Hampshire

When landlords in New Hampshire receive rental applications, they commonly charge an application fee to cover the costs of screening prospective tenants. Screening typically includes credit checks, background checks, and verification of income and rental history. These fees help landlords offset administrative expenses involved in processing applications.

What Are Application Fees Used For?

• Credit reports
• Criminal background checks
• Employment and income verification
• Administrative processing

Landlords must consider the reasonableness and transparency of application fees to comply with consumer protections and maintain good tenant relations.

---

Are Application Fees Refundable in New Hampshire?

General Rule: Application Fees Are Typically Non-Refundable

In New Hampshire, application fees are generally considered non-refundable. The rationale is that the landlord incurs expenses when screening each applicant, regardless of whether they approve the application or not. Therefore, the fee is intended to cover these incurred costs, not serve as a deposit or a guarantee.

Key Points on Refundability:

• No state law requires landlords to refund application fees upon denial.
• Application fees that cover screening and administrative costs are usually not refundable.
• If no screening is conducted or the landlord decides not to proceed before incurring expenses, some landlords might choose to refund fees as a courtesy, but this is not legally mandated.

When Might Fees Be Refundable?

• Overpayment: If a landlord charges more than the actual cost of screening, New Hampshire law may require returning the excess amount to the applicant.
• No screening performed: If the landlord collects a fee but does not conduct any screening activities, refunding the fee is advisable.
• Fee communicated as refundable: If the landlord explicitly states the application fee is refundable under certain conditions in the rental application or related documents, those terms should be honored.

---

Relevant New Hampshire Regulations and Best Practices

While New Hampshire does not have a specific statute explicitly governing application fee refundability, several consumer protection principles apply:

Truth in Billing

• Landlords should be transparent about application fees and what they cover.
• Provide applicants with a receipt or itemized explanation of the fee.
• Avoid charging excessive fees beyond the reasonable cost of screening.

Handling Denied Applications

• Inform applicants promptly if their application is denied.
• Explain the basis for denial clearly but without violating privacy laws or disclosing sensitive information.
• Clarify the application fee policy during the application process to prevent misunderstandings.

---

Practical Recommendations for New Hampshire Landlords

To maintain professionalism and minimize disputes regarding application fees, landlords should adopt clear and consistent policies:

1. Disclose Application Fee Policies Upfront

• Include language in your rental listing, application form, or lease documents that outline the amount, purpose, and refundability of the application fee.
• Example statement: “A non-refundable application fee of $XX will be charged to cover screening costs.”

2. Use Reasonable Fees Commensurate with Screening Costs

• Research the costs of credit and background checks to set appropriate fees.
• Avoid overcharging applicants to prevent claims of unfair practices.

3. Document Screening Expenses

• Keep receipts or invoices for services rendered when conducting tenant screening.
• This documentation supports the non-refundable nature of the fee if disputes arise.

4. Consider Partial Refunds If Screening Costs Are Lower Than Fees Collected

• If the fee exceeds the cost of screening, refund the difference promptly.
• Demonstrating fairness builds goodwill and reduces complaints.

5. Notify Applicants of Denial and Next Steps

• Communicate denial decisions quickly and professionally.
• Remind applicants of the application fee policy and extend courteous explanations if requested.

---

Conclusion

In New Hampshire, application fees charged to prospective tenants for screening purposes are generally non-refundable. Landlords incur real costs when processing applications, and the fee helps recover those expenses. However, transparency, reasonable fee amounts, and clear communication about fee policies reduce conflict and foster positive landlord-tenant interactions. While there is no explicit law mandating refunds upon denial, landlords should consider fairness and good business practices when handling application fees. Maintaining proper documentation and clear disclosures is essential for landlords to navigate tenant screening effectively.

---

By adhering to these practices, landlords in New Hampshire can confidently manage application fees within the scope of state expectations while building trustworthy and professional rental operations.