Can landlords restrict service animals in rentals?

Service Animals and Rental Properties in South Dakota: Legal Compliance for Landlords

In South Dakota, landlords must navigate certain legal obligations when it comes to allowing service animals in rental properties. Understanding these responsibilities is crucial to maintaining compliance with state and federal laws while ensuring a fair and accessible housing environment.

Service Animals Defined

Under both federal law and South Dakota regulations, a service animal is typically defined as a dog individually trained to perform tasks or do work for a person with a disability. This definition is primarily drawn from the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which South Dakota follows as part of its legal framework.

In some cases, other animals may be considered service animals or assistance animals if they meet specific criteria in relation to the tenant’s disability.

Can Landlords Restrict Service Animals?

Prohibition on Blanket Restrictions

In South Dakota, landlords cannot impose blanket restrictions that prohibit service animals in rental housing. This is consistent with federal civil rights protections that ensure people with disabilities have equal access to housing without discrimination.

• Landlords may not refuse to rent to a tenant solely because they require a service animal.
• Policies that exclude all animals, including pets, must still accommodate exceptions for service animals.
• Service animals are not considered pets under the law.

Reasonable Accommodation Under the Fair Housing Act

Because South Dakota follows the federal Fair Housing Act (FHA), landlords must provide reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities, including those who require service animals.

Key points for landlords include:

• Requests for accommodation: Tenants may request a reasonable accommodation to keep a service animal despite a no-pet policy.
• Verification: Landlords may request documentation or reliable verification that the tenant has a disability and the animal is a service animal or assistance animal, although this request must be reasonable and not overly intrusive.
• Interactive Process: Landlords should engage in a timely, good-faith interactive process with tenants to determine if the accommodation can be granted.

Restrictions and Conditions Allowed

While landlords cannot outright ban service animals, they may impose certain reasonable restrictions, provided these do not interfere with the tenant's rights. For example:

• Ensuring control: Tenants must keep service animals under control, such as on a leash or harness, when in common areas.
• Damage responsibility: Tenants can be held responsible for damage caused by the service animal beyond normal wear and tear.
• Disturbance prevention: If a service animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others or causes substantial property damage, landlords may have grounds to restrict the animal, following proper procedures.

Best Practices for South Dakota Landlords

To ensure compliance and avoid discrimination claims, landlords in South Dakota should adopt clear policies and procedures regarding service animals:

• Educate staff: Property managers and leasing agents should understand service animal rights and the accommodation process.
• Clear written policies: Outline how the accommodation request process works, what documentation is acceptable, and tenant responsibilities regarding service animals.
• Documentation handling: Maintain confidentiality of any medical or disability-related information provided.
• Prompt response: Respond promptly to accommodation requests to avoid unnecessary delays.
• Consistency: Apply policies consistently to all applicants and tenants to prevent discrimination.

Summary

In South Dakota, landlords must comply with both federal and state laws that prohibit restricting service animals in rental housing. Service animals are not considered pets, and landlords must make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities who rely on these animals. While landlords can enforce reasonable rules regarding control and responsibility, blanket bans on service animals are unlawful. Maintaining open communication and clear policies will help landlords fulfill their legal obligations and provide accessible housing to all tenants.

---

By adhering to these guidelines, landlords in South Dakota can avoid legal pitfalls and foster inclusive, legally compliant rental environments.